Dr. Nina Savelle-Rocklin
Binge Eating Solutions: What Works & What Doesn’t?
As a psychoanalyst specializing in eating disorders, I've heard countless stories about the misguided and often harmful advice people receive about binge eating solutions.
The impact of this advice can be profound, leaving people feeling misunderstood and unsupported.
To shed light on this issue, I asked my Facebook group to share the worst advice they've been given. The responses were both enlightening and disheartening.
Here, I’ll break down some of this terrible advice, explain why it’s so problematic, and offer tips on what actually works.
You can also check out my video on the 8 common myths about Binge eating for more information regarding popular misconceptions about binge eating
Table of Contents
- 1. “Just Choose Not to Binge”—Why Willpower Isn't Enough
- 2. “Complete a Weight Loss Challenge”—The Dangers of Quick Fixes
- 3. “Take Up Knitting”—Why Distraction Isn't the Answer
- 4. “Nothing Tastes as Good as Thin Feels”—The Toxicity of Diet Culture
- 5. “Just Brush Your Teeth Instead!”—A Misunderstanding of Emotional Needs
- 6. “Binge on Carrots Instead”—Why Healthy Substitutes Aren't the Solution
- 7. “Practice Mindful Eating”—Why It’s Not a Cure-All
- Binge Eating Solutions: The Path to Real Change
- Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
1. “Just Choose Not to Binge”—Why Willpower Isn't Enough
This is the most common yet damaging misconception about binge eating. It assumes that binge eating is simply a matter of choice or lack of self-control.
But binge eating isn’t about willpower; it’s a complex issue rooted in deep emotional struggles. When it comes to creating change, it's not logical—it's psychological.
Telling someone to “just stop” invalidates their struggle and ignores the deeper emotional issues at play.
Binge eating often serves as a coping mechanism for underlying pain, stress, or trauma.
It's not about a lack of willpower; it's an attempt to soothe or numb difficult feelings.
What Actually Works:
Overcoming binge eating requires going through three important steps:
- Understanding and addressing the root causes
- Developing new coping strategies
- Working through past traumas or unresolved emotional issues.
This process may involve journaling to explore your emotions, seeking support groups, or working with a therapist to uncover and heal from underlying issues.
2. “Complete a Weight Loss Challenge”—The Dangers of Quick Fixes
Weight loss challenges may provide short-term results regarding the number on the scale, but they don't address the underlying reasons for binge eating.
Once the challenge ends, the restrictive mindset often leads right back to bingeing.
These challenges promote an all-or-nothing mindset that can trigger binge eating.They focus solely on behaviors and numbers on a scale, ignoring the crucial emotional and psychological aspects of eating disorders.
What Actually Works:
- Sustainable change comes from understanding and addressing the root causes of binge eating, not from temporary diet fixes.
- Instead of short-term challenges, focus on developing a healthy, balanced relationship with food.
- Working with a professional to explore your relationship with food and body image can provide a foundation for long-term healing.
3. “Take Up Knitting”—Why Distraction Isn't the Answer
This advice assumes that binge eating is simply a matter of idle hands—as if emotional eating could be cured by busy work!
But binge eating is a complex psychological issue often rooted in emotional pain, trauma, or unmet needs.
Suggesting knitting as a solution trivializes the serious nature of binge eating disorders.
What Actually Works:
- Effective treatment for binge eating involves looking at what is eating at you, instead of focusing on what you’re eating.
- It involves learning to identify and process uncomfortable emotions. For instance, journaling can be a powerful tool to explore your feelings and understand the emotional triggers that lead to binge eating.
- It's about developing a toolkit of healthy coping mechanisms that address your emotional needs rather than simply distracting yourself.
4. “Nothing Tastes as Good as Thin Feels”—The Toxicity of Diet Culture
This toxic mantra, popularized by model Kate Moss, promotes shame and disordered eating.
It suggests that thinness should be our highest priority, even at the cost of pleasure and satisfaction from food.
This mindset often backfires, leading to more fixation on food and body image.
What Actually Works:
- Instead of valuing thinness above all else, the goal should be to promote a balanced, nurturing relationship with food and our bodies.
- People of all sizes can be happy, successful, and healthy. Working with a therapist to untangle the cultural messages about body size from your self-worth can be a critical step toward healing.
5. “Just Brush Your Teeth Instead!”—A Misunderstanding of Emotional Needs
The idea that fresh breath will deter binge eating is simply misguided. Binge eating isn’t about the taste in your mouth; it’s about attempting to fulfill unmet emotional needs.
A minty fresh mouth does nothing to address the underlying issues.
What Actually Works:
- Instead of focusing on superficial fixes, it's important to delve into the emotional and psychological factors that drive binge eating.
- Journaling, therapy, or engaging in creative activities that allow you to express your emotions can be more effective in addressing the root causes of binge eating.
6. “Binge on Carrots Instead”—Why Healthy Substitutes Aren't the Solution
Swapping one binge food for another doesn't solve the problem—it just shifts it.
Binge eating is not about the specific food; it's about using food to cope with emotions and internal conflicts.
Whether it’s carrots or cookies, the underlying issues remain unaddressed.
What Actually Works:
- Focus on healing your relationship with food by understanding that binge eating is a coping mechanism.
- Addressing the psychological aspects of eating behaviors is key.
- Working with a professional to explore the emotions behind your eating patterns can help you move beyond the need to use food as a coping mechanism.
7. “Practice Mindful Eating”—Why It’s Not a Cure-All
While mindful eating can be helpful for some, it’s not a cure-all for binge eating.
For many struggling with binge eating, trying to eat mindfully during a binge is like asking a tsunami to slow down.
What Actually Works:
- Mindful eating is effective for normal eating habits, but it doesn’t address the underlying emotional and psychological factors that drive binge eating.
- Instead, focus on identifying the emotions or situations that trigger your binge eating and developing healthier ways to cope with those feelings.
Binge Eating Solutions: The Path to Real Change
Overcoming binge eating isn't about quick fixes or simplistic solutions. It’s about understanding the deeper emotional drivers, learning new coping strategies, and healing your relationship with both food and yourself.
Remember, it’s not about what you’re eating—it’s about what’s eating “at” you.
When you identify the hidden reasons you’re turning to food and learn new ways of expressing and responding to yourself, real, lasting change happens.
If you’re struggling with binge eating, please don’t waste time on misguided “binge eating solutions.”
Seek help from a qualified professional who understands the complexity of eating disorders and can provide the support and tools you need to truly heal.
You deserve compassionate, effective care that addresses the root of the issue, not just the symptoms.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
If you're searching for effective binge eating solutions, you may have encountered a lot of conflicting advice. Understanding what truly works and what doesn't can be overwhelming.
To help further clear up common misconceptions and guide you toward real change, I've compiled this FAQ section.
Here, you'll find answers to some of the most frequently asked questions about overcoming binge eating, rooted in my experience as a psychoanalyst specializing in eating disorders.
1. What are the most common misconceptions about binge eating solutions?
Many people mistakenly believe that binge eating is simply a matter of willpower or lack of self-control.
Common misconceptions include the idea that you can just “choose not to binge” or that quick fixes like weight loss challenges or distracting activities can solve the problem.
These misconceptions ignore the deeper emotional and psychological issues that often drive binge eating.
2. Why doesn’t willpower work as a solution for binge eating?
Willpower alone is not enough to stop binge eating because binge eating is not just a behavioral issue—it’s a coping mechanism for deeper emotional struggles.
The urge to binge often stems from unresolved trauma, stress, or emotional pain, which cannot be resolved through sheer willpower.
3. Are weight loss challenges effective for overcoming binge eating?
No, weight loss challenges are not effective for overcoming binge eating. They may provide short-term results but do not address the underlying emotional and psychological reasons for binge eating.
In fact, these challenges often reinforce a restrictive mindset that can trigger more binge eating once the challenge ends.
4. Why is distraction, like knitting, not a good solution for binge eating?
Distraction techniques, such as knitting, may provide temporary relief but do not address the root causes of binge eating. Binge eating is often driven by unmet emotional needs, trauma, or pain.
Effective treatment focuses on understanding and processing these emotions rather than avoiding them.
5. How does diet culture contribute to binge eating issues?
Diet culture promotes the idea that thinness is the ultimate goal, often at the expense of mental and emotional well-being.
Phrases like “nothing tastes as good as thin feels” can create shame and encourage disordered eating behaviors, leading to a cycle of binge eating and fixation on body image.
The Author
Dr. Nina Savelle-Rocklin is a renowned author and podcast host and one of the nation’s leading psychoanalysts known for the psychology of eating. Her signature message of, “It’s not what you’re eating, it’s what’s eating ‘at’ you” has resonated with hundreds of thousands of listeners from around the globe in 40 countries. As founder of The Binge Cure Method, she guides emotional eaters to create lasting food freedom so they can take back control of their lives and feel good in their bodies.
Related Blogs
